Sunday, January 14, 2007

So our daughter was born the other day...

...and already, people are imposing European standards of beauty upon her! Goddamn them all to bloody hell.

Eight days ago, my wife gave birth to a beautiful baby girl. We thought she was perfect... until we had an Internet video conference with my in-laws in the Philippines. That's when we learned that she looks too Filipino to be perfect.

All they did was scrutinize the poor kid through the webcam, criticizing the lack of a fold in her eyelids, poking fun at her flat, flared nose and expressing disgust at her not-so-pale complexion. They even asked us to turn our kid from side to side just to see how high the bridge on her nose was! It was pathetic, almost comical.

And it's not just the in-laws who are this pathetic. Filipinos are sick, sick people. Pretty much any Filipino you'll ever meet is blindly ignorant of their self-denigrating approach to beauty. Growing up, my mother instructed me to pinch my nose regularly so that it would grow "narrow" and "tall," not wide and flat. For a race of brown, flat-nosed, slant-eyed people, it's astounding to see how we Filipinos can be so vigilant about upholding the Nazis' eugenic standards of Aryan purity.

It just breaks my heart to think that Filipinos, of all people, would see our daughter as less beautiful by virtue of her Filipino features. It would be nice if we could raise her in a world where her Filipino features (narrow eyes, brown skin, flat nose) would not get in the way of her confidence and self-esteem. But it's ironic that despite the progress made in maintaining civil rights and racial equality, it is often our own internalization of Western standards of beauty that allows our special racial characteristics to get in the way of our own confidence and self-esteem.

Sure, I've complained about this self-denigrating racism among Filipinos before. I've written volumes on the subject, addressed it in my poetry readings, even shot a satirical film about it. But I'm a father now, and it bothers me even more now than ever before. Seems that striving for whiteness is such a huge part of what it means to be a Filipino (and Filipino-American too), so much so that when I confront them about it, they look at me like I'm some mad lunatic. Like I should want nothing more than to be a white, round-eyed Caucasian. Just pick up any Philippine entertainment magazine and you'll see what I mean. No one in those magazines looks even remotely Filipino. It's all lily-white maidens and their round-eyed lovers with toothy grins, and ads for Eskinol skin whitening products.

I know that we're not the only ones who beat ourselves up by virtue of our special racial characteristics. I'm well aware of the light-skin preference amongst many African-Americans. And it disgusts me that people in Africa and Latin America have even suffered mercury poisoning from the skin whitening creams they slather on their bodies in their quest for whiteness. What disgusts me even more is how ophthalmologists worldwide continue to make a killing from the Asians who think that blepharoplasty is their ticket to beauty and social acceptance. It's a new brand of slavery, and it has very grave consequences! Why do we do this to ourselves? What can we do about it?

We all know that our minds have been infected by global pop culture and the mass media. We also know that producers of such media continue to produce content which lacks positive, accurate portrayals of people of color because WE CONTINUE TO CONSUME such media! How do we mitigate the demand for such inherently racist media? How do we inoculate our children from the lure of such pop culture?

I think I have the solution, but first I'd like to hear some of your thoughts. Do you come from a family of self-denigrating white supremacists? If so, how in the world do you deal with them? How do you deal with these issues when it comes to your children?

24 Comments:

Blogger meera bowman-johnson said...

OMG she's gorgeous!!!

I'm sorry to hear about your family responding that way, but you know everyone's family has to talk about the way a new baby looks. They just do. Not that that makes it okay.

I'm black and my husband is black and biracial. Our kids are three different colors (ranging from damn near white to caramel) with three different hair textures (ranging from golden curls to coarse). The girls are at polar extremes. I know they will hear comments (not from us and hopefully not from the extended family) about how different they look. Our job is to tell BOTH of them how beautiful they are. Constantly.

I know some feminist/post-fem moms don't want to go there, b/c they feel it might give girls the wrong idea about what's important (ie. valuing beauty over brains), but we'll tell them how smart they are too (that's a given). For girls of color it's just DIFFERENT. The media gives them far too much to be up against.

So if I were you, I'd just start telling that pretty little baby how beautiful she is now, and continue to do so...until she sees it for herself. And most of all, just enjoy being her parents and all of the joys and wonders of raising a daughter, it's really quite amazing.

Congratulations!

11:26 AM  
Blogger daddy in a strange land said...

Just followed your link over from ARP. First of all, congrats on the birth of your daughter, and welcome to fatherhood. :)

Second, you're writing about important stuff here. I coordinate Rice Daddies, at http://ricedaddies.com, don't know if you know us yet, but it's a group blog by AsAm dads. Would you be interested in being a contributor?

Head over there and comment on the latest post, too--it's about AsAms and philanthropy, you should write about and link to your post about giving.

Drop me a line, daddyinastrangeland@mac.com, and again, welcome to daddyhood-as you already know, being a father adds a whole new dimension to being down with the struggle. :)

A luta continua...

11:54 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Congratulations on the new baby! She is so beautiful. I can't believe how your family responded. My husband's family (who are cauasian) said something to the effect that despite her "slanted eye" our baby was beautiful. I wasn't in the room, but when I heard about it, I hit the roof. I still can't bear to look them in the eye.

Anyway, I got here from Rice Daddies and you are awesome! It's nice to see someone up in arms about important issues. I feel like when I try to talk to my Asian friends about similar issues they just blow me off.

6:06 PM  
Blogger honglien123 said...

I clicked over from Rice Daddies. Congratulations on your beautiful baby girl! I was actually talking to my Filipino friend about Asian standards of beauty a few weeks ago and she said the exact same thing!

4:47 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

i followed everybody else over here via rice daddies as well. congratulations on your newly minted rice daddie title and on the recent(ish) birth of your beautiful daughter.

your post hit so close to home on so many levels. i have so many mixed emotions about the ideal filipino beauty too - growing up with a facial deformity and raising my mixed race child who is constantly complimented on her fair skin and mestiza features.

i keep meaning to write a post about the following articles that talk about this. i thought maybe you'd be interested in reading them too, if you haven't already.

http://newsweek.washingtonpost.com/postglobal/glenda_gloria/2007/03/traffic_and_the_pretty_young_t.html

http://www.manilatimes.net/national/2007/mar/04/yehey/weekend/20070304week1.html

http://www.manilastandardtoday.com/?page=goodLife1_feb5_2007

12:02 AM  
Blogger asiangard said...

She is beautiful.
YOu know what is really funny and kind of ironic about the whole skin whitening thing?
How many white people bake themselves in the sun and at tanning salons and spray tan to make themselves brown...I mean, no one is happy with who they are it seems.

2:52 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am so with you on the Filipino self-hatred thing. Since I'm fairly light-skinned, Filipinos always comment how "mestiza" I look, like it's a compliment or something, or that I should say "thank you". Bleh. And geez, when they see my youngest son (he's so mestizo! look at his nose! how handsome!) I usually have to remind them that my other (browner, flatter-nosed heathens) are just as cute and SMART. It's ingrained, unfortunately in our culture, as well as others, that white is right.

11:45 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

your baby is so cute! and i love her nose.

4:11 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Congratulations Papa! Your daughter is beautiful. I am Chi-Am and my husband and I adopted a little girl from China. Among hearing "why didn't you adopt a son?" the other comment we heard from older relatives was "oh good, she's so fair, she almost looks half and half." or "She's so fair, she could easily pass for being part White." As if being full Chinese was a bad thing. WTF? But mostly it's the "fair" part that bugs, what if she weren't so fair, would she have been less accepted, especially considering her circumstance of being adopted into our family? We tell ourselves that it's a cultural and generational thing and that it's up to our generation to stop the madness of deciding the there is only one standard of beauty (western, etc).

Hope you get some sleep!
Christina

10:48 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think I might need to clarify (pre full cup of coffee here), that my husband is White and that's why the comments about our daughter "looking half White" doesn't bother us as much only in that we know that a lot of people see what they want to see -we've had so many strangers insist that our daughter is Hapa, but that's b/c they just assume seeing the two of us with her.

Anyway, I'm rambling. Congratulations again, followed you from Rice Daddies, which I found from Kimchi Mamas, and the list goes on and on.
Christina

10:52 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Your baby is so beautiful.

8:55 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Asian people think they're free but they're still very much enslaved. The really sad thing is that they can't even see it though it's right in front of them.

8:14 PM  
Blogger Rebecca Yu said...

Let's face it, Whites don't oppress so much as we oppress ourselves. Pride and respect start at home...

Or not. :(

10:27 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

i know this is an old entry, but i stumbled upon this site from the void of the web just now. to the point, i'm filipino (both parents from the provinces) with a 2-month old son (whose father is white). i think your daughter is very beautiful and precious. i think it is more important now to cherish your time with your new child than rant about an ignorance that will hopefully live and die in the philippines (especially since you wrote this JUST AFTER SHE WAS BORN)...or at least just with your in-laws. have more faith in your child, in your child's future, and in the generations that have raised us. despite their outrageous flaws there is a lot more to them than we typically give them credit for. why criticize those who are so clearly insecure about their brown features, features that you yourself appreciate, instead of accept/praise them? lead by example. it's better to improve your argument than raise your voice.

~camille

6:53 PM  
Blogger Stars said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

4:57 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

They're not actually 'Filipino features' since there is no such thing as a Filipino race, there is a Filipino people made up of the mixture of several races, the main three being Malay, Spanish, and Chinese, the main three ancestries of most Filipinos.

They're actually Malay features (brown skin, wide flat nose with no nose bridge), but in the Philippines under Americanization, the word Filipino has transformed from a nationality into a racial label, even when it's not actually a race, but the word 'Filipino' has substituted and become synonymous with 'Malay'.

4:58 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Also, you can't say that the celebrities in Philippine magazines don't look Filipino, since ALL of them are Filipino. Filipinos don't have to look one way (brown skin, wide nose, black hair) since there are variations within the Filipino people with how we look, and again, there is no such thing as a Filipino race, but there is a Filipino people made up of the mixture of Malay, Spanish, and Chinese, my aunt is Filipina, but she has green eyes and wavy brown hair, as do my grandparents, my other aunt, and my uncle, my uncle has a sharp nose and spanish features reflecting our spanish blood but brown skin reflecting our malay ancestry, my aunt has white skin, green eyes, but her eyes are small reflecting our chinese blood, my mom has white skin, wavy hair reflecting the spanish blood, but her hair is black reflecting the asian ancestry, my grandma had green eyes, wavy black hair, white skin, my grandfather had a pointed nose, wide hazel eyes, wavy hair from his spanish ancestry, but his skin was not as white as my grandmother's, but it was not as dark as a pure malay, it was in between reflecting the mixed lineage, it's all part of being Filipino, people can't say all Filipinos are brown and wide nose, it gets annoying, because it makes Filipinos who don't have that feel as if they're less Filipino, when it couldn't be far from the truth

5:06 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

BTW, your daughter is gorgeous! Just don't listen to them, understand them, they're not as educated as you, so they can't see the error of their ways.

5:09 AM  
Blogger Gav said...

In God's eyes we are all equal. Therefore we should know everyone is beautiful no matter how they look.
You should disregard their comments, she looks very adorable, as every other baby.

9:31 PM  
Anonymous LatinaFilipina said...

Your child look cute and face like an angel. Please never say your child looks way too Filipino or that those models on magazines are no Filipino because of their looks. I'm Filipino too but have round eyes, tall & pointed nose and Spanish/Arab/Latino features. I'm Filipino too but have round eyes, tall & pointed nose and Spanish/Arab/Latino features. Me I'm maybe 1/2 Spanish but I still Filipino because I am born here. WE all have different faces. Although 97% of Filipinos are of pure Malay blood or posses Asian Malay looks but thing is not all are like that. Its why many of my online friends always mistaken me as Middle Eastern/Latina. THough I speak Spanish but I always say I'm Filipina and its so happens that I look like them & speak their language. I'm proud to be Filipino.

6:47 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yeah, I'm happy for you about your daughter, but I'm Filipino-American, so I am kinda offended when you said that "Filipinos are sick, sick people."

9:52 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

First, "Filipinos are sick, sick people", and now you're saying that your daughter is too "Filipino"? You are sick, for thinking that Filipinos are ugly and you should be happy for your daughter looking like a Filipino.

9:58 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree with LatinaFilipina. I am proud to be Filipino, and no one is gonna change that no matter how much they trash talk about the great Philippines. Douglas MacArthur loved the Philippines, and my mom is Filipino, and my dad's American, and they fell in love. So I don't care about what you say against Filipinos and Filipino-Americans, cause I'm not listening any more.

10:08 PM  
Blogger SoulSnax said...

wow, Ms./Mr. Anonymous. I guess reading comprehension is NOT one of your strengths. nowhere did I say "that Filipinos are ugly." You are clearly missing the point.

In a nutshell, I'm trying to point out how Filipinos are sick people for aspiring for Western standards of beauty. They are sick sick people because they consider their unique Malay features (dark skin, narrow eyes, broad nose) as a hindrance to beauty. That's why many of them use so many skin whiteners. And if they can afford it, opt for Asian blepharoplasty to make their eyes less Asian, and more Western. Why can't they see themselves as beautiful just they way they are?

12:53 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home